The Gilded Age – Class Documentary Project

Instructors:

Rachel Duffy

Marc Ducharme

May, 2005

Adapted from:

The Gilded Age WebQuest - Documenting Industrialization in America

By: Thomas Caswell and Joshua DeLorenzo  

Site: www.oswego.org/staff/tcaswell/wq/gildedage/student.htm

PROJECT OUTLINE NAVIGATION
INTRODUCTION
TASK
PROCESS
SEGMENTS
ROLES
RESOURCES
EVALUATION
CONCLUSION

 

Introduction

You are a member of a film production studio that has recently been hired to produce a documentary about the Gilded Age of American history.

American novelist Mark Twain coined the term "Gilded Age" in an effort to illustrate the outwardly showy, but inwardly corrupt nature of American society during the industrialization of the late 1800's.

The documentary will need to highlight the many aspects of society that made up the Gilded Age, including: technological innovation, big business, urbanization, immigration, and reaction to the period.

The Gilded Age WebQuest: Documenting Industry in America

The Task

You and your team will be responsible for producing one specific segment of the  documentary. Each segment production team will be responsible to:

  • Research the theme for the group's segment
  • Collaboratively create a 5-10 minute documentary segment using Microsoft Photo Story (including appropriate images. voice-over narration, etc.)
  • Preview the assembled documentary (including all five segments)
  • Use segment study guides to informally assess the effectiveness of the documentary segments.

Project Mission Sheets (Segment Producer should check here to start every day)

Process

 

•  Consult the grading rubric to make sure you create the best possible documentary. 

•  Each member of the group conducts research in order to contribute materials essential to the production of your group's segment. Research should incorporate a variety of resources including text and review books, materials from the Media Center , as well as Internet resources. A list of all of the research sources will be kept so that it can be incorporated into a written and Photo Story slide-based Works Consulted list using proper MLA citation.

 

•  Divide up the four roles among your group members.

 

•  Access the web page for your specific role listed in the Group Roles section. There, you will find a thorough description of your role and the responsibilities associated with it.

•  Organize the group's research and prepare it for use in the segment study guide and Photo Story presentation.

 

•  Prepare a study guide and script to use for the narration in your documentary.

 

•  Construct your group segment collaboratively using Photo Story.

 

•  Edit and fine tune your segment before submitting it to the teacher.

 

•  Preview the assembled documentary (including all five segments), using the study guides.

 

•  Each group will assign individual grades based on the work of each member, and the teacher's evaluation of the group segment.

 

 

Documentary Segments

TECHNOLOGY SEGMENT
Technology, and an abundance of natural resources, was the driving forces behind the Industrial Revolution in the United States . The telegraph, railroads, the telephone, and ultimately the use of electricity led to the shift from an agrarian to an industrial America .

Standard Oil Refinery in California

Required Content:

  • Industrial Revolution
  • Use of Natural Resources:
    • Iron
    • Coal
    • Oil
  • Transcontinental Railroad
  • Inventors and their Inventions:
    • Samuel F. B. Morse
    • Henry Bessemer
    • Alexander Graham Bell
    • Thomas Alva Edison

Chinese railroad workers.

 

BIG BUSINESS SEGMENT
Laissez-faire capitalism ruled the day during the beginning of the Industrial Revolution in the United States . In this atmosphere of unbridled money-making, numerous types of business organizations gave rise to Big Business. Were the leaders of these companies Captains of Industry or Robber Barons? While some used ruthless business practices to wipe out their competition and earn large profits, others gave enormous sums of money to charities and their communities.

Required Content:

  • Laissez-Faire Capitalism:
    • Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations
  • Forms of Business Organization:
    • Monopoly
    • Conglomerate
    • Pool
    • Trust
    • Holding Company
  • Entrepreneurs (Robber Barons or Captains of Industry?):
    • Andrew Carnegie
    • John D. Rockefeller
    • J. Pierpont Morgan
    • Jay Gould
    • Henry Ford
  • Conspicuous Consumption
  • Philanthropy

 

URBANIZATION SEGMENT
Urbanization was a direct result of the Industrial Revolution in the United States . Burgeoning factories were centralized in cities which offered a central location for resources and workers to fuel their production. Immigrants and displaced rural workers flooded cities in the hopes of finding employment. Throughout the Gilded Age there were several positive, as well as negative, effects that can be attributed to urbanization.

Required Content:

  • Negative Effects of Urbanization:
    • Housing (tenements, slums, etc.)
    • Health (disease, sanitation, etc.)
    • Working Conditions (child labor, etc.)
    • Political Machines (Tamany Hall, graft, etc.)
  • Positive Effects of Urbanization:
    • New Technologies (elevators, skyscrapers, street lighting, water and sewage systems, etc.)
    • Cultural Benefits (museums, theaters, parks, libraries, education, etc.)
  • Philosophies:
    • Puritan Work Ethic
    • Social Darwinism (Horatio Alger, etc.)

NYC Tenament

 

IMMIGRATION SEGMENT
The United States has always been a nation of immigrants. During the Gilded Age, immigration to America increased tremendously. More people came to the United States than ever before, but they were also coming from different places, and in doing so they added to the culture of America . Was America becoming a "melting-pot," or a "salad-bowl" of differing cultures?

Required Content:

  • Periods of Immigration:
    • Colonial Immigration (time period, place of origin, difficulties, etc.)
    • "Old" immigration (time period, place of origin, difficulties, etc.)
    • "New" Immigration (time period, place of origin, difficulties, etc.)
  • Reaction Against Immigration:
    • Nativism
    • Know-Nothing Party
    • Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 ("Yellow Peril")
    • National Origins Acts (1924, 1929)
  • Theories of Immigration:
    • "Melting-Pot" Theory
    • Assimilation
    • " Salad-Bowl" Theory (Pluralism)

A Thomas Nast Cartoon: Pacific Chivalry

 

REACTIONS SEGMENT
The Gilded Age was a period of immense change in the United States . All of the abuses and problems of the time generated many different reactions- most directed at reform. Slowly, government regulations began to reign in the abuses of big business. At the same time, social reformers actively sought to correct the problems evident in American cities.

Required Content:

  • Granger Movement:
    • Railroad Practices (pools, rebates, etc.)
    • Railroads=Public Utility
    • Bloc Voting
    • Granger State Laws
    • Munn v. Illinois (1877)
    • Wabash Case (1886)
    • Interstate Commerce Act (1887)
  • Sherman Antitrust Act (1890)
  • Unionism:
    • Collective Bargaining
    • Knights of Labor
    • American Federation of Labor
    • International Ladies' Garment Workers Union
  • Early Reformers:
    • Thomas Nast
    • Jane Addams ( Hull House)

Another Thomas Nast Cartoon: It is a duty and honor to vote.

 

Group Roles

LEAD HISTORIAN
The lead historian takes charge of organizing the research for their group's particular assigned segment. While the majority of the research will be the responsibility of the lead historian, it is not the sole responsibility of the lead historian.

The lead historian will also assign and monitor the research activities of the other members. The lead historian will collect, categorize and filter the information that he/she and the other production team members collect. The lead historian will also keep records of the sources consulted for the segment. Finally, the compilation of the final Works Consulted list using MLA format will be his/her responsibility.

Main responsibilities:

  • Collection of historical data related to and relevant to the group's segment.
  • Assignment of research activities to other group members:
    • It is also expected that the lead historian ensure that a variety of resources (book, periodical, encyclopedia, Internet, etc.) are being used in the data collection process by all group members.
    • The lead historian should also hold the other group members accountable for their efforts and ensure that the information collected is cited properly and of the highest possible quality.
  • Verification of the accuracy of the collected data.
  • Organization, collection, categorization of historical data acquired by other group members.
  • Ensure that the information collected is presented in a clear and organized manner for inclusion in the final documentary.
  • Compilation of the final Works Consulted documents (submitted in a written format in addition to appearing at the end of the final production) using proper MLA citation .
  • Serve as a resource when needed in the other areas of production.

Ohio State Monitor headline, 1918.

MEDIA SPECIALIST
As the media specialist, you will focus on acquiring the raw multimedia materials for inclusion in the Photo Story documentary being produced by your group. The multimedia materials collected will include: pictures, graphics, audio and possibly video. Materials may be scanned in from print sources (scanning is your responsibility; see your teacher for assistance if needed).

There will be a folder created in Student Groups folder (Humanities_A > Photo_Story > segment title) in which other members of your group will submit materials for your collection, sorting and cataloging. Make sure to back-up all of the submitted materials to your own personal Network folder, at the end of each work day, to ensure that none of the materials are lost or tampered with. You should keep an accurate record of the materials available and consider renaming any file names which are confusing for ease of use by the Photo Story engineer. It is expected that you will play a significant role in the creation of the Photo Story presentation and should assist the Photo Story engineer during final production.

Main responsibilities:

 

PHOTO STORY ENGINEER
The Photo Story engineer will focus on the actual construction of the group's segment. The engineer will need to communicate with the other members of the group to ensure that the final product reflects the input of all members. The engineer will also work very closely with the media specialist to obtain the multimedia materials to be used in the creation of the final presentation, and to gain assistance in the final stages of production. It will be essential that the engineer begin the framework of the presentation as soon as possible (even while the other members are still researching information and acquiring materials) to ensure that the presentation is ready by the given deadline. The engineer will oversee the narration of the voice-over for inclusion in the final presentation and work with the other members of the group during the recording process (refer to the Technology consultant for assistance if needed).

Mining engineers ca. 1890-1910.

Main responsibilities:

•  Utilization of materials acquired by the Media Specialist

•  Animation of the presentation so that it will run automatically.

•  Recording narration voice-over for the group's presentation.

 

 

SEGMENT LEAD PRODUCER
The segment producer is mainly responsible for ensuring that a timetable for the production is set and adhered to by the group. This task involves the coordination of the entire team's efforts and overseeing many aspects of the planning and production phases. A key role of the segment producer will be also be designing, writing and editing the voice-over narration script for the final production. The segment producer in effect manages the production and keeps the group on-task during all stages of production. The segment producer will also be responsible for acting as liaison between the group and the instructor, if and when problems or concerns arise. The segment producer will be involved in all areas of the assignment, assisting in research, multimedia collection, and the final Photo Story production and narration recording.

Children waiting outside of a Texas movie theater in 1903.

Main responsibilities:

~ Media Specialist

~ Photo Story Engineer

~ Lead Historian

 

 

Resources

REMEMBER!! To record and cite properly each artifact or information source as you conduct your research and collect materials for your presentation.

Electronic Resources
Click here to view online resources.

Local Resources
Our local library hold many resources that could be useful and improve your presentation and understanding of the information you are responsible for gathering. Images can be scanned from book resources to add to your presentation.

 

Evaluation

Individual Grading
While cooperation and team work are key to this project, it is not uncommon for some group members to work to a lesser or to a greater degree than others. To address this concern, individual grades will be determined based on the points earned by the segment, and based on the group's evaluation of each of its members.

The segment producer will keep a record of the daily attendance and activities of each group member. After the group segment has been graded, the group will collaboratively determine the grade of each member of the group.

For example, if the group segment earns a total of 20/24 possible total points, or 83%, the group will need to decide how to fairly distribute 332 percentage points (83 project grade X 4 members) among the members of the group. Attendance, work ethic, and cooperation are some of the factors that a group should use in order to determine how many points to award to each member. If problems arise during this process that cannot be peaceably worked out by the members of the group, they should consult the teacher for assistance.

An immigrant receives an eye examination.

A sample individual grade distribution follows:

Total Group Grade = 20/24 or 83%. With 4 group members there are now 332 total points that can be assigned to each individual group member.

For example:

Joe

=

75%

Sally

=

91%

Tom

=

96%

Sue

=

70%

GroupTotal

=

332

 

PROJECT GRADING
As we discussed in class, a high-quality documentary has a certain look and feel to it, which we are going to try to emulate using Photo Story. Based on the criteria that we developed in class, please keep the following grading rubric in mind as you collaboratively create your segment:

Criteria

Score

Factual Content- The information included in the documentary is accurate and relevant to the topic, and includes all of the required items listed on the Documentary Segments page.

 

Use of Primary Sources -Several relevant primary sources (e.g., photographs, Supreme Court rulings, Federal legislation, personal accounts, etc.) have been used to provide information about the content contained in the documentary segment.

 

Media Use -The sounds, images, animations, and slide transitions that are used are both relevant and purposeful.

 

Organization -The documentary segment is organized in a logical manner, making it easy to understand the information that is being presented.

 

Citation -The last slide of the Photo Story presentation contains an MLA-style Works Consulted listing all of the resources used for this project (e.g., textbook, review book, web pages, etc.).

 

Narration/Interview(s) -Narration and/or interview(s) are used as the primary means of transmitting information for the documentary. The narration and/or interview(s) are relevant and compliment the media selected for the documentary segment.

 

Study Guide -The study guide acts as an outline of the documentary, providing students with a resource to review the material presented. The study guide should closely follow the presentation of the documentary.

 

Formatting -The segment maintains the formatting required to create a uniform class documentary (e.g., background color, font size, font type, font color, etc.) and is between 8 and 12 minutes in length.

 

Total Points

 

 

Grade

 

 

Each of these criteria will be rated according to the following point scale:

Score

Meaning

3

Excellent -The criteria has been met in every possible way, and may even exceed expectations.

2

Acceptable- This criteria has been mostly addressed, however, there is room for improvement.

1

Sub par- Some elements have been met, but most of the criteria fails to be addressed.

0

Incomplete- The criteria has not been addressed in any meaningful way or has not been completed.

 

 

 

Conclusion

After completing this Learning Quest, you will understand the major concepts and themes of the Gilded Age in American history. Check your understanding of these ideas by considering the following essential questions:

 

  Return to top of page